Skip to main content

Hebron, 3 video segments: Soldiers overlook settlers' violent actions, take measures when Palestinians throw stones

On 16 August 2014, after 6:00 P.M., settlers and Palestinians began throwing stones at each other behind the Beit Hadassah settlement in the city of Hebron. The settlers were throwing stones from a spot near a military guard post, yet the soldiers stationed there did nothing to stop them. Nonetheless, the soldiers used crowd control measures against the Palestinians who were throwing stones, and even detained two, one of them a boy.

Soldiers behind Beit Hadassah stand by while a female settler throws stones close by, 16 August 2014, 6:17 P.M.:

Filmed by Narmeen Abu Hayah

Soldiers behind Beit Hadassah stand by while nearby masked settlers throw stones, 16 August 2014, 6:30 P.M.:

Filmed by Nisreen Sader

The soldiers detained Mahmoud Abu Hayah, a B'Tselem camera volunteer who also recorded the incident. They kept him there for two hours after the incident, but did not take him to the police station.

Some nine months ago, on 10 November 2013, the same B'Tselem camera volunteer filmed soldiers standing by at the very same spot while a settler threw stones:

Filmed at 4:00 P.M. by Mahmoud Abu Hayah

Each of the three segments indicates that the soldiers disregarded their duty to protect the Palestinians in the area during these incidents: they took no steps to stop the settlers' violent actions, while taking measures only against violent actions by Palestinians. Moreover, it appears that the soldiers made no attempt to identify masked settlers or detain any settlers at all and hold them until the police could arrive to ensure proper law enforcement.

The reality created by Israel's occupation of Hebron gives rise to frequent skirmishes between settlers and Palestinians in the city. The military is duty-bound to take action to enforce the law on both parties. Refraining from action against violent settlers conveys a message that settlers may attack Palestinians and their property and get military protection to do so.