Skip to main content

The writing is on the wall: Defense Minister must act to prevent next "Price Tag" incident

Anticipating possible settler reprisals to the evacuation of the Ulpana Hill, human rights organizations call on security services to prepare in advance.

Five human rights organizations sent an urgent letter to Defense Minister Ehud Barak, Judea and Samaria Police District Commander Amos Yaakov, and GOC Central Command General Nitzan Alon, demanding a preconceived and proactive approach to the possiblitly of violent activities carried out by extreme right-wing activists against Palestinians in the days leading up to the removal of five houses from Ulpana Hill in the settlement of Beit El.

The signatory organizations, Hamoked: Center for the Defense of the Individual, Yesh Din, B’Tselem, the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI), and Rabbis for Human Rights, state that based on past experience there is a real concern that Israeli citizens will carry out violent acts of reprisal against Palestinians in the context of a policy known as “price tag.” This concern is substantiated by the arson and vandalizing of a mosque in the village of Jaba’, which occurred despite the fact that the evacuation of Ulpana is, according to various publications, being carried out with consent. The organizations also stress that past experience shows that when security forces are adequately organized, damage to Palestinians and to their property is prevented..

"Israel’s obligation to protect the well being of the Palestinians is anchored in law and in High Court rulings and is not an act of kindness,” write the organizations. “Even if it requires the allocation of significant resources, it is necessary in order to fulfill the duty to protect the security of Palestinians, and past experience demonstrates that in situations in which the security forces were not adequately prepared, settlers harmed Palestinians and caused damage to their property. We ask that you act to prevent violence against Palestinians as the imminent eviction approaches."

The organizations demand the following from security forces:

  • Provide clear guidelines to all military and police forces regarding their obligation to protect the well being and property of Palestinians
  • Enforce the law on lawbreaking settlers and place police and security guards in areas prone to violence
  • If settlers succeed in trespassing on Palestinian lands and villages despite the preemptive preparation of security forces, instruct the forces in the field to disperse such settlers immediately
  • Arrest lawbreakers and bring them to trial
  • Allow freedom of movement and activity to Palestinian fire and rescue services
  • If their movement is restricted, Israeli fire and rescue services must act swiftly to evacuate the wounded and to put out fires